Being interrupted is one thing. Having your knowledge questioned, your expertise overridden, and your voice treated as less credible is another. A communication study examines how mansplaining operates in academic workplaces—and why its effects go beyond a single conversation.
Universities are expected to be spaces where ideas are exchanged, expertise is valued, and people are encouraged to contribute. But what happens when some voices are treated as more authoritative than others?
In Undermined and Interrupted: Mansplaining as Epistemic Exclusion in Academia, Assistant Professor Dominic Yasay of the Communication Program examines how two women faculty members experienced and responded to mansplaining in a university in Cagayan de Oro City.
Mansplaining refers to explaining something to a woman in a condescending or dismissive manner, often while disregarding her knowledge or expertise. The study shows how this behavior can become more than an uncomfortable interaction: it can undermine a woman’s authority as a professional and knowledge producer.
When expertise is questioned instead of heard
The participants described experiences in which male colleagues or superiors interrupted them, dismissed their explanations, or questioned their professional judgment.
In one instance, a participant’s explanation of her academic discipline was cut short and replaced with a simplified interpretation of the field. In another, a superior questioned a participant’s professional decision in an area connected to her work.
The issue was not simply disagreement. It was the way their knowledge was treated as less credible or less authoritative.
Why speaking up is not always easy
The study also found that workplace hierarchy and cultural expectations shaped how the women responded.
Values such as kaikog (relational sensitivity and restraint), panag-uyon (social harmony), and pagpailub (endurance) influenced their decisions to delay a response, remain silent, or withdraw from difficult interactions.
These responses should not be mistaken for passivity. In contexts where challenging a superior may strain professional relationships or carry consequences, silence can become a way of managing risk.
But the effects can linger. Participants described frustration, anxiety, self-doubt, reduced willingness to contribute ideas, and questions about their professional worth.
Small interactions, larger institutional consequences
The findings point to a broader concern: workplace inequality is not sustained by formal policies and positions alone. It can also take shape in everyday conversations—in who gets interrupted, whose ideas are taken seriously, and who is expected to prove their expertise repeatedly.
So what can individuals do?
If you are in a discussion: Give others time to finish. Avoid interrupting or explaining concepts they already know.
If someone’s expertise is dismissed: Help bring the conversation back to their contribution. For example, say, “I’d like to hear the rest of her explanation.
If you lead a team: Make space for different voices, acknowledge contributions, and address repeated patterns of interruption or dismissal.
If you recognize this behavior in yourself: Pause before correcting or explaining. Ask whether your input is needed, and listen before assuming you know more.
If you experience or witness repeated incidents: Where safe and appropriate, document what happened and seek support through trusted colleagues or institutional mechanisms.
These actions do not place the responsibility for fixing workplace inequality on women who experience it. Institutions must also establish clear policies, reporting mechanisms, and accountability measures that address gendered communication practices.
Beyond being heard, women deserve to be taken seriously
A qualitative case study involving two participants cannot represent every woman’s experience in academia. But it offers a closer look at how gender, organizational authority, and cultural expectations can intersect in everyday professional communication.
The study shows that simply having women in the room does not mean their voices carry weight. They also need to have their expertise taken seriously and their contributions respected.
Read the full paper here: https://ejournalprisma.com/index.php/ojs/article/view/259
ABOUT THE RESEARCH
Title: Undermined and Interrupted: Mansplaining as Epistemic Exclusion in Academia
Researcher: Dominic D. Yasay
Affiliation: College of Communication, Art, and Design, University of the Philippines Cebu
Published in: PRISMA: Gender and Education e-journal, Volume 3, Issue 1 (2026)